Reynolds was named the Colonial Athletic Association Defensive Player of the Year while earning First Team All-CAA and NCCSIA All-State recognition in his senior year. He was the Seahawks’ second-leading scorer with four goals and 13 points in 2019. As a junior in 2018, he was named to the All-Tournament Team at the CAA Championship after scoring a goal against Hofstra in the semifinals. Appeared in 40 games, making 34 starts for Louisville before transferring to UNC Wilmington.
Reynolds played club soccer for Cheltenham Town FC, Reading FC and Oxford United. He trained with the first team with Cheltenham Town and scored eight goals with 25 assists in 60 appearances.
Reynolds was a psychology major at UNC Wilmington. His sister, Jade, played soccer at College of Charleston.